Comments on: ImageJ vs. Pixcavator http://inperc.com/blog2/2008/02/27/imagej-vs-pixcavator/ Computer vision, image analysis, and related mathematics Thu, 17 Feb 2011 13:25:51 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.1.3 By: Computer Vision for Dummies » ImageJ vs. Pixcavator, a follow-up http://inperc.com/blog2/2008/02/27/imagej-vs-pixcavator/comment-page-1/#comment-85 Computer Vision for Dummies » ImageJ vs. Pixcavator, a follow-up Tue, 04 Mar 2008 14:16:23 +0000 http://inperc.com/blog2/2008/02/27/imagej-vs-pixcavator/#comment-85 [...] In the last post I provided a list that compared the capabilities of ImageJ (without plug-ins) and Pixcavator 2.4 in analysis of gray scale images. Then I submitted the link to the ImageJ’s forum. [...] [...] In the last post I provided a list that compared the capabilities of ImageJ (without plug-ins) and Pixcavator 2.4 in analysis of gray scale images. Then I submitted the link to the ImageJ’s forum. [...]

]]> By: Bob Mottram http://inperc.com/blog2/2008/02/27/imagej-vs-pixcavator/comment-page-1/#comment-81 Bob Mottram Thu, 28 Feb 2008 22:49:07 +0000 http://inperc.com/blog2/2008/02/27/imagej-vs-pixcavator/#comment-81 I use the fast binarization method described here http://pubs.iupr.org/DATA/2007-IUPR-11Sep_1129.pdf I use the fast binarization method described here http://pubs.iupr.org/DATA/2007-IUPR-11Sep_1129.pdf

]]> By: Duane http://inperc.com/blog2/2008/02/27/imagej-vs-pixcavator/comment-page-1/#comment-80 Duane Wed, 27 Feb 2008 23:57:37 +0000 http://inperc.com/blog2/2008/02/27/imagej-vs-pixcavator/#comment-80 There's some things you forgot: ImageJ is free, Pixcavator is $150 ImageJ runs on my Mac, Pixcavator doesn't I can call ImageJ from MatLab, Pixcavator? There’s some things you forgot:

ImageJ is free, Pixcavator is $150
ImageJ runs on my Mac, Pixcavator doesn’t
I can call ImageJ from MatLab, Pixcavator?

]]> By: Peter http://inperc.com/blog2/2008/02/27/imagej-vs-pixcavator/comment-page-1/#comment-79 Peter Wed, 27 Feb 2008 21:26:14 +0000 http://inperc.com/blog2/2008/02/27/imagej-vs-pixcavator/#comment-79 >>Isn’t ImageJ with plugins the fairer comparison? Bill, yes it would be more fair. But it would take a lot more work. Plus I would have to compare to Pixcavator SDK, to be fair. >> I would hazard to say that everything in Pixcavator is surely available through a plugin Mark, this sounds like a challenge! I have $100 here saying you are wrong. >>Isn’t ImageJ with plugins the fairer comparison?

Bill, yes it would be more fair. But it would take a lot more work. Plus I would have to compare to Pixcavator SDK, to be fair.

>> I would hazard to say that everything in Pixcavator is surely available through a plugin

Mark, this sounds like a challenge! I have $100 here saying you are wrong.

]]> By: Mark Burge http://inperc.com/blog2/2008/02/27/imagej-vs-pixcavator/comment-page-1/#comment-78 Mark Burge Wed, 27 Feb 2008 21:03:57 +0000 http://inperc.com/blog2/2008/02/27/imagej-vs-pixcavator/#comment-78 I agree with Bill, comparing ImageJ without plugins does not really make sense. ImageJ is designed to be a solid base which is extended via plugins. I would hazard to say that everything in Pixcavator is surely available through a plugin (http://rsbweb.nih.gov/ij/plugins/index.html). Mark Burge http://www.imagingbook.com/ I agree with Bill, comparing ImageJ without plugins does not really make sense. ImageJ is designed to be a solid base which is extended via plugins. I would hazard to say that everything in Pixcavator is surely available through a plugin (http://rsbweb.nih.gov/ij/plugins/index.html).

Mark Burge
http://www.imagingbook.com/

]]> By: Bill http://inperc.com/blog2/2008/02/27/imagej-vs-pixcavator/comment-page-1/#comment-77 Bill Wed, 27 Feb 2008 20:55:00 +0000 http://inperc.com/blog2/2008/02/27/imagej-vs-pixcavator/#comment-77 Isn't ImageJ with plugins the fairer comparison? Good to know about the option of Pixcavator, which I had not seen before. Isn’t ImageJ with plugins the fairer comparison?

Good to know about the option of Pixcavator, which I had not seen before.

]]>